Skip to Content

16 Super Creepy Halloween Punch Ideas

Bubble, bubble, no toil, no trouble!

Headshot of Christopher MichelBy Christopher Michel
apple cider punchpinterest icon
Ian Palmer

Halloween is the time for making punch. You're going to be so busy planning the party games, decorating the house, and coming up with the perfect costume, that you don't want to get too fussy with the drinks. Punch lets everyone help themselves, so you don't have to be stuck by the bar cart, and you can spend more time hosting and enjoying the evening. Need help coming up with good Halloween appetizers? We've got you covered there, too.

1

Apple Cider Punch with Shrunken Apple "Heads"

apple cider punch
Ian Palmer

Our tasty cider punch gets a big increase on the spooky-scale with these carved shrunken heads! You'll need about a week for the heads to properly shrivel, so plan ahead.

Get the recipe for Apple Cider Punch.

2

Witch's Brew Punch with Ice Hands

witch's brew punch with ice hands
Ian Palmer

Guests are sure to feel a little tingle creeping up their spine when they go for a ladle and an icy hand floats up to wave hello!

Get the recipe for Witch's Brew Punch with Ice Hands.

3

Tart Cherry Eyeball Punch

halloween punch tart cherry punch in glasses with lychee nut blackberry eyeballs for garnish
Brian Woodcock

This drink is so easy, you'll scream (with delight). It's great both as a mocktail and with alcohol.

Get the recipe for Tart Cherry Eyeball Punch.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
4

Pomegranate-Rum Punch

halloween punch pomegranate rum punch with orange garnish in glasses by a dutch oven cauldron smoking with dry ice
Brian Woodcock

This bloody delicious cocktail features spiced rum, cinnamon, and a surprising ingredient for extra flavor (and color): hibiscus tea.

Get the recipe for Pomegranate-Rum Punch.

5

Cranberry Mulled White Wine

halloween punch
Becky Luigart-Stayner

Mulled wine is a traditional fall treat, but if you find the red version to be a bit heavy, this lighter take, flavored with fall spice, cranberries, and a touch of honey, may just become your new seasonal favorite!

Get the recipe for Cranberry Mulled White Wine.

6

Warm Tea-and-Cider Punch

halloween punch warm tea and cider in a pot with cups on the ground by a wooden sled
Brian Woodcock

If your Halloween happens on a day when the temps are dipping, brew up a big batch of this hot toddy. The seasonal cider flavors and hot cup will keep everyone toasty. Want to keep it going for a while? Serve it in a slow-cooker!

Get the recipe for Warm Tea-and-Cider Punch.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7

Slow Cooker Pear Cider

halloween punch slow cooker pear cider
Becky Luigart-Stayner

October is prime pear season. Switch up your hot cider with this delicious, warming concoction. It's kid-friendly, but you can add a splash of your favorite whiskey or cognac to stiffen it up.

Get the recipe for Slow Cooker Pear Cider.

8

Hot Toddy with Charred Oranges

halloween punch hot toddy with charred oranges
Hector M. Sanchez

If your Halloween hosting tradition involves gathering by fire or grill in the front yard as you wait for trick-or-treaters, consider mixing up this sweet treat for the adults to warm themselves with.

Get the recipe for Hot Toddy with Charred Oranges.

9

Pumpkin Spice White Russian

halloween punch pumpkin spice white russian
Ren Fuller

It's pumpkin spice season! A big batch of this makes for an excellent party drink — especially if you're dressing up like The Dude for Halloween.

Get the recipe for Pumpkin Spice White Russian.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
10

Golden Gobbler Cocktail Punch

halloween punch golden gobbler cocktail punch
Becky Luigart-Stayner

Looking for a drink that's more tasty than gimmicky? This batch cocktail of tea, ginger beer, and bourbon is unbeatably good.

Get the recipe for Golden Gobbler Cocktail Punch.

11

Apple Cider Punch

halloween punch apple cider punch
Kana Okada

Dark rum takes this seasonal blend of sweet and sparkling juices to the next level.

Get the recipe for Apple Cider Punch.

12

"Ale"ments Punch

halloween punch
Frances Janisch

We love this warming blend of dark rum, pale ale, and fresh apples all season long.

Get the recipe for "Ale"ments Punch.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13

Old Faithful Punch

halloween punch
Frances Janisch

This delicious chilled combo of bourbon, grapefruit juice, elderflower liqueur, and mint is unexpectedly delicious. But go easy! It's also quite stiff.

Get the recipe for Old Faithful Punch.

14

Classic Margaritas

halloween punch classic margaritas
Getty Images

When it comes to having a green punch for Halloween, Margaritas make a great drink. (Honestly, there's never a bad time to make margaritas.) Want to spook it up? Add a little food coloring and some black sanding sugar to the rim. Voilà!

Get the recipe for Classic Margaritas.

15

Spiced Cranberry Ombre Punch

halloween punch spiced cranberry ombre punch

This colorful, rummy twist on a cranberry cocktail is like all the best flavors of fall distilled into one drink.

Get the recipe for Spiced Cranberry Ombre Punch.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
16

Witch's Wicked Punch

halloween punch witch's wicked punch
Kate Sears

Lime sherbet and lemon-lime seltzer make for a delightfully foamy and eerie green halloween punch. If you want to adult it up, add gin or vodka to taste.

Get the recipe for Witch's Wicked Punch.

Watch Next
 
preview for Country Living US Section - Food & Drinks

100+ Genius Halloween Ideas for 2023

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Logo
twitter icon
youtube icon
facebook icon
instagram icon
pinterest icon
Hearst Lifestyle and Design Group - A Part of Hearst Digital Media

A Part of Hearst Digital Media

We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back.

©2023 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy NoticeCA Notice at CollectionYour CA Privacy Rights/Shine the LightDAA Industry Opt OutTerms of UseSite Map
Cookies Choices